VA loan denied? Manual underwriting and second looks

Loan Options / VA Loans

VA loan denied? Manual underwriting and second looks

What to do after a VA loan denial, when lenders use manual underwriting, and what the underwriter looks at.

★★★★★ 5.0 on Google  |  Company NMLS #1835856

At a glance

  • Used when automated approval isn't possible
  • No VA minimum credit score
  • Residual income carries real weight
  • Lender guidelines vary
(386) 882-9980

Talk with a licensed loan officer

Manual underwriting

Most VA loans are approved with the help of an automated underwriting system. When that system can't give an approval, for example because of thin credit, past credit problems or a higher debt-to-income ratio, a VA loan can sometimes still be approved through manual underwriting, where an experienced underwriter reviews the whole file.

VA minimum credit scoreNone set by the VA
VA maximum DTINone; 41% is a guideline
Key testResidual income
AvailabilityVaries by lender

VA loan denied? What to do next

Start by finding out which rule stopped your file. Each lender applies VA rules plus its own standards, and you can ask which one applied.

  1. Get the reasons in writingThe lender has to notify you within 30 days of receiving your completed application. The notice lists the specific reasons, or tells you how to request them within 60 days.
  2. Ask whose rule it wasAsk whether the reason came from a VA requirement or from that lender's own guideline, called an overlay.
  3. Check your credit reportIf the lender used your report, you can get a free copy by asking within 60 days of the notice. Dispute any mistakes with the credit bureau and the company that reported them.
  4. Ask for a second lookBring the notice, your Certificate of Eligibility and recent income documents to another lender. Ask whether that lender manually underwrites VA loans.

Read more by reason

If you think a lender treated you unfairly, you can submit a complaint to the CFPB.

When manual underwriting is used

  • The automated system returns a 'Refer' instead of an approval
  • You have little or no traditional credit history
  • Recent credit events need a closer look, such as a past bankruptcy
  • The file needs explanations an automated system can't weigh

What the underwriter looks at

A manual review looks at the full picture: how you've handled payments over the past year, stability of income, cash reserves, and especially residual income. When the debt-to-income ratio is above 41%, the VA asks for a closer review and a written justification, unless residual income is at least 20% above the minimum. Strengths like reserves, a long job history or a small increase in housing payment can help the file.

If you don't have credit scores, lenders can sometimes build a nontraditional credit history from rent, utility and insurance payments.

Why a second look matters

The VA sets the program rules, but each lender adds its own requirements, called overlays. One lender may have a higher credit score floor or may not manually underwrite at all, while another will. FLO Mortgage closes most VA loans in its own name, and we can review your file against VA rules and the guidelines that apply to your loan.

Turned down somewhere else? Call us at (386) 882-9980. A licensed loan officer can go through your notice with you. A second look doesn't guarantee approval.

Questions, answered

What should I do first if my VA loan was denied?

Get the reasons in writing. The lender has to give you the specific reasons, or tell you how to request them within 60 days of the notice.

Can I apply with another lender after a VA loan denial?

Yes. Each lender sets its own standards on top of VA rules. A new application doesn't guarantee a different result, and the new lender may check your credit again.

Is there a minimum credit score for a VA loan?

The VA does not set one. Lenders set their own minimums, and they vary, which is why a second look can help.

What is VA manual underwriting?

It's a full review of your file by an underwriter when automated approval isn't available. It weighs payment history, income stability, reserves and residual income.

Can I get a VA loan with a high debt-to-income ratio?

Possibly. The VA has no maximum DTI. Above 41%, lenders look for strong residual income and other compensating factors.

Can I get a VA loan with no credit score?

Some lenders can build nontraditional credit from rent, utilities and other payment history and manually underwrite the loan.

Does manual underwriting take longer?

Usually a bit, because more documentation is reviewed. Getting documents in quickly helps.

More answers in the FLO Mortgage VA FAQ.

This is not a commitment to lend. All loans are subject to credit approval, underwriting guidelines, property eligibility and program availability. Lender requirements may be stricter than the program guidelines described here. Not all applicants will qualify. Figures reflect 2026 VA guidelines and may change without notice. FLO Mortgage, LLC, company NMLS #1835856. Licensed mortgage lender in Florida (MLD2621), Georgia and Tennessee. Equal Housing Opportunity. FLO Mortgage is not affiliated with or endorsed by the U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs or any government agency. Licensing & Disclosures.

Local, licensed help

Talk a VA loan through with a FLO loan officer

Every FLO Mortgage loan officer can walk you through this program, run the numbers for your situation and compare it with your other options. Have questions? Call our main office at (386) 882-9980.

Ready to see your numbers?

Answer a few quick questions and a local loan officer will follow up with your options.

FLO Mortgage is a private, state-licensed company, not a government agency. It is not affiliated with or endorsed by the U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs, HUD/FHA, USDA or any other government agency.

© FLO Mortgage, LLC. All rights reserved. Company NMLS #1835856.