How Do I Choose Between a Local Mortgage Broker and a Big Bank?

To choose between a local mortgage broker and a big bank, get a written Loan Estimate from each in the same week, for the same loan amount and program, and compare the fees, the cash to close and the person you’ll be working with. A broker can shop your file with several lenders. A bank usually offers only its own loans. For a simple file, either one can work. For self-employed income, a past credit problem, a condo or a VA or USDA loan, having more than one lender to try gives you better odds of finding one whose rules fit.

What’s the difference between a mortgage broker and a bank?

A bank lends its own money, so you get one set of loan programs and one set of underwriting rules. If your file doesn’t fit those rules, the answer is no, or a different product from the same menu.

A mortgage broker is licensed to take your application and place it with a wholesale lender. The broker compares programs and pricing from several lenders and picks the one that fits your file. You still close with a lender, and your loan officer stays your contact until closing.

Some local companies do both. FLO Mortgage lends on some loans as a correspondent lender and brokers others, such as FHA loans and HELOCs, to partner lenders. On any loan, the Loan Estimate shows which lender is making it.

When does a local broker make more sense?

Your file has a wrinkle. Self-employed borrowers, buyers with a recent credit event, condo buyers and investors often get different answers from different lenders. A broker can send your file to a lender that takes that kind of loan instead of trying to fit it into one bank’s rules.

You want one person to call. With a small local company, the loan officer who took your application usually answers the phone through closing. You’re less likely to have to explain your file again to someone new.

You’re buying in a competitive market. Listing agents sometimes call the buyer’s loan officer before they accept an offer. A loan officer who knows the area and picks up the phone can tell them where your file stands.

You want local knowledge. In Florida and Georgia, a local loan officer can tell you early how flood zones, homeowners insurance costs and condo association rules could affect your loan, before those issues show up late in underwriting.

When does a big bank make more sense?

You already bank there and get a relationship discount. Some banks lower their pricing for customers who keep checking or investment accounts with them. Ask for it in writing on the Loan Estimate, then compare that figure with the broker’s quote.

You’re moving to a state your local lender doesn’t serve. A local mortgage company can only take your application in the states where it holds a license. FLO Mortgage, LLC is licensed in Florida, Georgia and Tennessee. If you’re buying somewhere else, a national lender may be the practical choice.

Your file is simple. With W-2 income, strong credit and a standard single-family home, most lenders will offer similar programs. Price and service decide it.

How do I compare a broker and a bank fairly?

  • Ask both for a Loan Estimate. Federal rules require a lender to send you this standard three-page form within three business days after you apply. Because every lender uses the same form, you can compare the two side by side.
  • Request quotes in the same week, on the same day if you can. Rates and pricing can change daily, so two quotes taken a week apart don’t tell you much.
  • Use the same scenario. Give both the same loan amount, program, term and lock period.
  • Read page 2. Section A lists origination charges, the fees for making the loan. Section J shows total closing costs. Compare both lines across the two Loan Estimates.
  • Look at service, too. Ask who handles your file and how fast they answer. A cheaper loan that misses your closing date can cost you the house.

The CFPB has an interactive Loan Estimate guide that goes through each section of the form.

What should I ask a lender before I choose?

  • Who will handle my file day to day, and how do I reach them?
  • Are you lending your own money on this loan, or placing it with another lender?
  • Which programs fit my situation, and why that one?
  • Can you send a Loan Estimate I can compare with another lender’s?
  • How long do your loans usually take from contract to closing?

You can look up any loan officer or mortgage company on NMLS Consumer Access to see which states they’re licensed in. If a lender won’t put numbers in writing, get a quote somewhere else.

Broker or bank in four points

  • A broker can place your loan with several lenders. A bank usually offers only its own loans.
  • Your file decides it. A file with a wrinkle benefits from more lenders to choose from, and a simple file can go either way.
  • Compare written Loan Estimates gathered in the same week, for the same scenario.
  • Check the loan officer’s license on NMLS Consumer Access before you apply.

If you’re buying or refinancing in Florida, Georgia or another state where we’re licensed and want a Loan Estimate to compare, contact FLO Mortgage or call (386) 882-9980. Our loan program comparison lays out conventional, FHA and VA side by side.

General information only, not a commitment to lend or financial advice. Subject to credit approval and program guidelines. FLO Mortgage, LLC is a licensed mortgage broker/correspondent, company NMLS #1835856. Joy McCoy Flores, Broker Owner, individual NMLS #1096400. Equal Housing Opportunity. 212 Moody Blvd, Flagler Beach, FL 32136. (386) 882-9980.

FLO Mortgage is a private, state-licensed company, not a government agency. It is not affiliated with or endorsed by the U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs, HUD/FHA, USDA or any other government agency.

© FLO Mortgage, LLC. All rights reserved. Company NMLS #1835856.